Friday, June 3, 2011

Matthew Shepard Act

Matthew Shepard, his Murder, and the Ensuing Trial

Matthew Shepard was a 21 year old student at the University of Wyoming. On the night of October 6, 1998, he was brutally tortured and beaten for being gay. He did not die the same night that he was attacked, but suffered for another 5 days until he died in Poudre Valley Hospital in Fort Collins, Colorado. The beating and resulting death of Matthew sparked rage and controversy everywhere. Soon after Matthews death, police found a bloody gun along with Matthews shoes and wallet in a truck used by Russel Arthur Henderson and Aaron James McKinney, Matthews murderers. Both of the men were arrested and convicted of murder. They failed in an attempt to get their girlfriends to provide alibis for them, not that they would have done much good with the evidence already there. During the trial McKinney tried to plea a thing called gay panic defense which would be where he would have been temporally driven to insanity by sexual advances made by Matthew. As if. They repeatedly tried to say that they had only wanted to rob him, they knew he was from a rich family, he was a small and easy target, and they had tried to gain his trust by pretending to be gay. Overwhelming evidence provided that they had taken Matthew from an establishment, brought him to a remote part of Laramie, tied him to a fence post, beaten him, and smashed his skull with a blow from the side of a pistol.

The only spots not covered with blood on Matthews face were the streaks wiped clean with his tears.

Both of his murderers were given consecutive life sentences with no possibility of parole. Neither of them were charged with a hate crime because the laws in Wyoming did not dictate sexual orientation to be one of the things qualifying as a hate crime.

New Ideas for Legislation

After the murder of Matthew Shepard, many people felt the urge to push attacks on an individual based on sexual orientation to be prosecutable as a hate crime. The following are the attempts made to do so that failed or may have had some success.

State Levels:
The Wyoming legislature attempted to pass a bill defining certain attacks on an individual based on the victims identity to be a hate crime in a following session. The bill failed because of a tie in votes, 30-30.

Federal Level:
President Bill Clinton renewed attempts to extend hate crimes to include homosexual individuals, women, and people with disabilities. The efforts were rejected by the House of Representatives in 1999.
Both houses of Congress passes a legislation including these efforts, but was struck down after President Bush threatened to veto it in 2000.


The Matthew Shepard Act

People were not soon to forget this crime of hate. The demand for the nations law to recognize this as a hate crime did not end. Efforts continued on state and nation levels to pass legislation to provide homosexuality as a basis to be prosecuted as a hate crime. Motivated by the murders of Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr., a black man tied up and decapitated in Jasper, Texas, an act was proposed that came to be known as the Matthew Shepard Act (Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr. Hate Crime Prevention Act.) This act would provide for the following if passed.
  • The measure would expand the 1969 Federal Hate Crime Law to include attacks based on gender or gender identity, sexual orientation, and disability.
  • The requirement that the person attacked be involved in a federally protected activity, like voting or going to school, to be considered a hate crime would be removed.
  • Federal Authorities would have more of an ability to investigate a supposed hate crime that the local authorities might choose not to pursue.
  • For the fiscal years of 2010 through 2012, $5 million dollars would be provided to pay for the investigation and prosecution of hate crimes.
  • The FBI would be required to track statistics on hate crimes based on gender and gender identity. All other types have been tracked before and continued.
However needed and sought for, the act had some opposition, as I am sure most do. The founder of the organization Focus on the Family, which I personally know from listening to their radio shows with my Papa, stated that the measure would "muzzle people of faith who dare to express their moral and biblical concerns about homosexuality." Senator Jim DeMint of South Carolina, said the bill was not needed, would violate the 14th amendment, and would utterly lead to the prosecution of "thought crimes." Jim DeMint must be homophobic and seems close to the Iranian presidents statement saying that Iran did not have one single gay man or women in it, what with the 'not needed' thing and all.

The act would obviously not consider speaking against another person to be a hate crime, and most concerns that it would do so were not needed. On October 22, 2009, Congress passed the bill. Finally, some days later on October 28, the bill was signed into law by the hand of President Obama.

This tragic death of Matthew Shepard has brought this country a great shock. Matthew is responsible for the legislation that has prevented the abusers of others like him from getting away and forced the states to recognize homophobia as a basis of a hate crime. God bless him. Thank you Matthew.


No comments:

Post a Comment