Wednesday, July 6, 2011

LGBTQ History in California Schools

A new bill, proposed by Democratic San Francisco Senator, Mark Leno, is pushing to allow LGBTQ history as part of the existing list of groups to be included in social science teaching.

How far has it been?

On Tuesday, July 5, 2011, the bill (SB48) was passed by the assembly 49-25. The majority of votes being democrats, along with one republican (As I recently learned from a friend is a near party-line vote.) Then it went off to await the governor's signing. The governor, Jerry Brown, has not said if he plans on signing the bill into law or not. Being a Democrat, odds seem in favor that he will.

What Exactly Is It?

Democratic Assemblyman Tom Ammiano has said that the bill is crucial due to bullying that happens to gay students daily. John Perez, the first openly gay Assembly Speaker, said this about the bill, "This bill will require California schools to present a more accurate and nuanced view of American history in our social science curriculum by recognizing the accomplishments of groups that are not often recognized." California will be the first state in America to require LGBTQ contributions to be taught in public schools. 


Opposition


Republican Assemblyman, Tom Donnelly, has stated his outright dis-approval of the bill, "I think it is one thing to say that we should be tolerant, but it is another thing entirely to teach my children that this lifestyle is good." He has also stated that the bill is being used to promote the "homosexual agenda" to children as young as the age of six, though there has not been a specific grade decided on for the matter to be introduced into the curriculum. "Our founding fathers are turning over in their graves," Tom Donnelly has said. Assemblyman Chris Norby, citing an already crowded curriculum, "I do not think this helps the teaching of history, I think it is a distraction."


Defense


This bill, as stated by John Perez, does not promote any sexual motives, but rather removes censorship in textbooks. With several recent gay suicides, another purpose of the bill would be to reduce bullying of LGBTQ students and in a way prevent suicides. Regardless of parents that may not approve of the bill, it would not devote an entire semester to LGBTQ rights, it would only require that people that contributed to society be recognized and let students know of that persons sexual orientation. Knowing that historic people were LGBTQ would help that struggling gay student to realize he or she is not alone. It could prevent the loss of a young life that felt alone in the world and was not helped by bullying that could be prevented. This bill is for humans. This bill is for life.





Monday, June 13, 2011

Dont Say Gay Bill - Tennessee's New Law For Ingnorance

Tennessee Senator Stacey Campfield has crossed into a new low. For the past six years he has tried to pass a bill that has just recently found some success. What is this bill? The 'Don't Say Gay Bill,' or at least that is what its opponents call it. Now you probably want to know what it is about to have any public notice. Maybe you have already heard of it, or you want to know more. But, first lets learn a little about who though of it.

Who-

Knoxville's Senator Stacey Campfield. In my opinion, he is homophobic. Actually that is not just me, most people will say the same thing if asked. That was a little, not much about him, but I never specified how much a 'little' was.

What it is-

The 'Don't Say Gay Bill' was created by Senator Stacey Campfield. In his words, the bill would give parents the opportunity to address the gay issue. In the words of the bill, "Any instruction or material provided or made available at or to a public elementary of middle school shall be limited to natural human reproductive science. Yep, that's right, Senator Stacey Campfield wants to ban the discussion of being gay in schools across Tennessee, or at least all those before high school. The bill had originally said that no discussion of any sexuality besides heterosexuality, but the wording was changed to make it easier for the lawmakers to accept, as I see it.

What Would The Bill Do?

With a bill banning the discussion of homosexuality, schools would be discouraged from passing new anti-discrimination rules to stop bullying of LGBT students. With a ban on speaking of homosexuality, how would the rules be communicated to students?

Opponents say that the bill would 'prevent counseling for children struggling with their own sexuality, both at home and at school.' The children would see themselves being discouraged from speaking of it at school and, therefore, would feel like it should be ignored and not try to get help in understanding it and accepting who they are. The suicide rate that people have so tried so stop among LGBT teens could potentially increase due to this bill, there is no good in it.

The bill could also prevent teens from participating in school clubs like the GSA (Gay Straight Alliance) without parental permission. Which some think would make teens who most need the groups fear joining because closeted teens would have to face the very likely question, "Well, honey, why would you want to join that group?" A National Survey in 2009 showed that violence and bullying toward LGBT students had decreased in schools with GSA groups.

What I Think of Campfield's Bill-

To the best of my knowledge, those school groups are held at lunch or during school time, and would not need parental permission. Campfield is only trying to keep LGBT children quiet about their sexuality at school. Very many people have said that they believe he is trying to hide homosexuality and hope it will just go away. I am one of those people. What Stacey Campfield has proposed is a way to shut up children and push their mental health to the back of the minds of people who can most help them. Campfield doesn't want to hear about gays. For what he is doing, he should be thrown out of office on the spot for a crime against children with the same severity as what President Clinton did to be impeached. This world has no room for people like Senator Stacey Campfield.


Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Catholic Charities Situation in Illinois

The Charity-

Catholic Charities is a nation wide organization that is working hard to aid the poor and provide services that second in number only to the federal government. In the state of Illinois, this greatly appreciated agency has been contracted by the state to handle a major part of foster care and adoption services.

What Caused Controversy-

The Illinois Religious Freedom Protection and Civil Unions Act. Under this new law, passed by the state on June 1, 2011, Catholic Charities would have to stop discriminating against gay and unmarried couples (Civil Unions.) To be more clear, the act gives same-sex and opposite-sex couples alike, the right to enter into civil unions which are to be held to the same standard as marriage (but by no means a substitute for the real thing.) Partners in Civil Unions would be treated as spouses and would receive many of the same benefits that married couples would, including adoption and foster care. This law, that would serve to advance the rights of gay and lesbian people as well as the straights who chose not to go through the ceremonial passage of marriage, has upset the organization so much that they have decided to terminate all adoption and foster care services rather than allow children from their agency into the loving care of gay and lesbian people. This was not the first time this has happened, recently in Washington, DC, Catholic Charities chose to stop providing benefits for their married employees rather than provide them for gay couples, too. Also, in Boston, the Catholic Charities there has already announced intentions to stop adoption services rather than comply with state laws. If Catholic Charities continues with discrimination, they would be violating several anti discrimination laws and would be in danger of losing their state funding.

The Case-

Catholic Charities is funded with government money to perform their adoption and foster care services, a reported $30 million dollars annually by the state. Then when the state decides to turn a leaf for human rights and make civil unions for homosexual and heterosexual couples legal. When you are running on state funding, you should follow the word of the law. Being a religious organization, they have tried saying special rights are in order when it comes to the law. One article I read concerning this situation made a good comparison for this. The author compared not letting lgbt people adopt to denying food to poor families with lgbt members (If I could find the article, I would post the link but the article seems to have disappeared.) No organization should be granted special rights with the law, religious or not. Instead of trying to work things out with the state, Catholic Charities decided to cut to the chase. So, they sued the state for their right to discriminate. Of course, what they said the lawsuit was for was, and this is what a chief operating officer of one of the branches in Illinois personally said, the lawsuit was needed because of a 'lack of clarity' over whether the agency would have to accommodate unmarried couples.

"We are filing suit because of our commitment to children and families in this state. We provide foster-care service for roughly one our of five children in the state of Illinois. If we were forced out, in our view, the worst case scenario would be pretty devastating to the child welfare system."-Anthony Riorden, Chief Operating Officer of Catholic Charities of Peoria, Illinois.

The court process may take months to complete and the organization is trying to put pressure on the state by suspending their adoption services, as previously stated. This trial is utterly stupid. Their is no place for such people like them to act so childish and put their religious and political agendas before that of children needing a home.


Friday, June 3, 2011

Matthew Shepard Act

Matthew Shepard, his Murder, and the Ensuing Trial

Matthew Shepard was a 21 year old student at the University of Wyoming. On the night of October 6, 1998, he was brutally tortured and beaten for being gay. He did not die the same night that he was attacked, but suffered for another 5 days until he died in Poudre Valley Hospital in Fort Collins, Colorado. The beating and resulting death of Matthew sparked rage and controversy everywhere. Soon after Matthews death, police found a bloody gun along with Matthews shoes and wallet in a truck used by Russel Arthur Henderson and Aaron James McKinney, Matthews murderers. Both of the men were arrested and convicted of murder. They failed in an attempt to get their girlfriends to provide alibis for them, not that they would have done much good with the evidence already there. During the trial McKinney tried to plea a thing called gay panic defense which would be where he would have been temporally driven to insanity by sexual advances made by Matthew. As if. They repeatedly tried to say that they had only wanted to rob him, they knew he was from a rich family, he was a small and easy target, and they had tried to gain his trust by pretending to be gay. Overwhelming evidence provided that they had taken Matthew from an establishment, brought him to a remote part of Laramie, tied him to a fence post, beaten him, and smashed his skull with a blow from the side of a pistol.

The only spots not covered with blood on Matthews face were the streaks wiped clean with his tears.

Both of his murderers were given consecutive life sentences with no possibility of parole. Neither of them were charged with a hate crime because the laws in Wyoming did not dictate sexual orientation to be one of the things qualifying as a hate crime.

New Ideas for Legislation

After the murder of Matthew Shepard, many people felt the urge to push attacks on an individual based on sexual orientation to be prosecutable as a hate crime. The following are the attempts made to do so that failed or may have had some success.

State Levels:
The Wyoming legislature attempted to pass a bill defining certain attacks on an individual based on the victims identity to be a hate crime in a following session. The bill failed because of a tie in votes, 30-30.

Federal Level:
President Bill Clinton renewed attempts to extend hate crimes to include homosexual individuals, women, and people with disabilities. The efforts were rejected by the House of Representatives in 1999.
Both houses of Congress passes a legislation including these efforts, but was struck down after President Bush threatened to veto it in 2000.


The Matthew Shepard Act

People were not soon to forget this crime of hate. The demand for the nations law to recognize this as a hate crime did not end. Efforts continued on state and nation levels to pass legislation to provide homosexuality as a basis to be prosecuted as a hate crime. Motivated by the murders of Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr., a black man tied up and decapitated in Jasper, Texas, an act was proposed that came to be known as the Matthew Shepard Act (Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr. Hate Crime Prevention Act.) This act would provide for the following if passed.
  • The measure would expand the 1969 Federal Hate Crime Law to include attacks based on gender or gender identity, sexual orientation, and disability.
  • The requirement that the person attacked be involved in a federally protected activity, like voting or going to school, to be considered a hate crime would be removed.
  • Federal Authorities would have more of an ability to investigate a supposed hate crime that the local authorities might choose not to pursue.
  • For the fiscal years of 2010 through 2012, $5 million dollars would be provided to pay for the investigation and prosecution of hate crimes.
  • The FBI would be required to track statistics on hate crimes based on gender and gender identity. All other types have been tracked before and continued.
However needed and sought for, the act had some opposition, as I am sure most do. The founder of the organization Focus on the Family, which I personally know from listening to their radio shows with my Papa, stated that the measure would "muzzle people of faith who dare to express their moral and biblical concerns about homosexuality." Senator Jim DeMint of South Carolina, said the bill was not needed, would violate the 14th amendment, and would utterly lead to the prosecution of "thought crimes." Jim DeMint must be homophobic and seems close to the Iranian presidents statement saying that Iran did not have one single gay man or women in it, what with the 'not needed' thing and all.

The act would obviously not consider speaking against another person to be a hate crime, and most concerns that it would do so were not needed. On October 22, 2009, Congress passed the bill. Finally, some days later on October 28, the bill was signed into law by the hand of President Obama.

This tragic death of Matthew Shepard has brought this country a great shock. Matthew is responsible for the legislation that has prevented the abusers of others like him from getting away and forced the states to recognize homophobia as a basis of a hate crime. God bless him. Thank you Matthew.