Catholic Charities is a nation wide organization that is working hard to aid the poor and provide services that second in number only to the federal government. In the state of Illinois, this greatly appreciated agency has been contracted by the state to handle a major part of foster care and adoption services.
What Caused Controversy-
The Illinois Religious Freedom Protection and Civil Unions Act. Under this new law, passed by the state on June 1, 2011, Catholic Charities would have to stop discriminating against gay and unmarried couples (Civil Unions.) To be more clear, the act gives same-sex and opposite-sex couples alike, the right to enter into civil unions which are to be held to the same standard as marriage (but by no means a substitute for the real thing.) Partners in Civil Unions would be treated as spouses and would receive many of the same benefits that married couples would, including adoption and foster care. This law, that would serve to advance the rights of gay and lesbian people as well as the straights who chose not to go through the ceremonial passage of marriage, has upset the organization so much that they have decided to terminate all adoption and foster care services rather than allow children from their agency into the loving care of gay and lesbian people. This was not the first time this has happened, recently in Washington, DC, Catholic Charities chose to stop providing benefits for their married employees rather than provide them for gay couples, too. Also, in Boston, the Catholic Charities there has already announced intentions to stop adoption services rather than comply with state laws. If Catholic Charities continues with discrimination, they would be violating several anti discrimination laws and would be in danger of losing their state funding.
The Case-
Catholic Charities is funded with government money to perform their adoption and foster care services, a reported $30 million dollars annually by the state. Then when the state decides to turn a leaf for human rights and make civil unions for homosexual and heterosexual couples legal. When you are running on state funding, you should follow the word of the law. Being a religious organization, they have tried saying special rights are in order when it comes to the law. One article I read concerning this situation made a good comparison for this. The author compared not letting lgbt people adopt to denying food to poor families with lgbt members (If I could find the article, I would post the link but the article seems to have disappeared.) No organization should be granted special rights with the law, religious or not. Instead of trying to work things out with the state, Catholic Charities decided to cut to the chase. So, they sued the state for their right to discriminate. Of course, what they said the lawsuit was for was, and this is what a chief operating officer of one of the branches in Illinois personally said, the lawsuit was needed because of a 'lack of clarity' over whether the agency would have to accommodate unmarried couples.
"We are filing suit because of our commitment to children and families in this state. We provide foster-care service for roughly one our of five children in the state of Illinois. If we were forced out, in our view, the worst case scenario would be pretty devastating to the child welfare system."-Anthony Riorden, Chief Operating Officer of Catholic Charities of Peoria, Illinois.
The court process may take months to complete and the organization is trying to put pressure on the state by suspending their adoption services, as previously stated. This trial is utterly stupid. Their is no place for such people like them to act so childish and put their religious and political agendas before that of children needing a home.
No comments:
Post a Comment